Dan Robin Posted May 7, 2010 Report Share Posted May 7, 2010 Somebody has already expressed an opinion about the season and general.... but what are your opinions about the single players? What 'mark' would you give to them,for their performances in this season? To me (on the Italian tv/internet I've seen only 7-8 matches so my marks are a result of my impressions in those matches and a mix of match reports and comments made by the majority of the fans in this forum) ( '/' -> no mark because I haven't see them or they played not much) Gerken 7+ Henderson 6 Collis / Carey 6,5 Fontaine 7 McCombe 5 Nyatanga 6- Ribeiro 7 Orr 7 B.Wilson / McAllister 6,5 Sawyer 6 Hartley 7,5 LJ 6,5 Sno 6,5 Skuse 7 Elliott 7 Williams / Sproule 6,5 Campbell-Ryce 6 Maynard 9,5 Haynes 7,5 Clarkson 6,5 Saborio 5 Akinde / Iwelumo 7 Agyemang / Maierhofer / Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Riaz Posted May 7, 2010 Report Share Posted May 7, 2010 Gerken 5.5 Henderson 6 Carey 6 Fontaine 7 McCombe 4 Nyatanga 6 Ribeiro 7 Orr 7 McAllister 5 Sawyer 7 Hartley 7 LJ 6 Sno 6.5 Skuse 8 Elliott 7 Sproule 6 Campbell-Ryce 6.5 Maynard 9 Haynes 8.5 Clarkson 7 Saborio 4 Akinde 6 Iwelumo 8 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
chowie Posted May 7, 2010 Report Share Posted May 7, 2010 ah, thought this was gonna be a thread about spotting players shopping! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Frome Red Posted May 7, 2010 Report Share Posted May 7, 2010 All my marks are for the performances in the matches the players have played and not the amount of games that's why players like Rib's and Sawyer have 8 as they was outstanding imo in the 3-4 games they played. Gerken 7 Henderson 6 Collis / Carey 6.5 Fontaine 7 McCombe 4 Nyatanga 6 Ribeiro 8 Orr 7 B.Wilson / McAllister 6 Sawyer 8 Hartley 7 LJ 6 Sno 5.5 Skuse 7 Elliott 7 Williams 6 Sproule 6 Campbell-Ryce 6.5 Maynard 9.5 Haynes 7.5 Clarkson 6 Saborio 5 Akinde 4 Iwelumo 8.5 Agyemang 1 Maierhofer 5 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SyntaxtheRed Posted May 7, 2010 Report Share Posted May 7, 2010 Gerken 6.5 Henderson 6 Collis / Carey 6.5 Fontaine 7 McCombe 5 Nyatanga 6 Ribeiro 7 Orr 7 B.Wilson / McAllister 6,5 Sawyer 6.5 Hartley 7,5 LJ 5.5 Sno 6 Skuse 7 Elliott 6.5 Williams / Sproule 6.5 Campbell-Ryce 6 Maynard 9 Haynes 7 Clarkson 6 Saborio 5 Akinde / Iwelumo 7 Agyemang 4 Maierhofer / Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BCFC Jordan Posted May 7, 2010 Report Share Posted May 7, 2010 Gerken 7 Henderson 6 Collis / Carey 7 Fontaine 7 McCombe 5 Nyatanga 6 Ribeiro 8 Orr 6 B.Wilson / McAllister 6 Sawyer 6.5 Hartley 7 LJ 6 Sno 5.5 Skuse 7.5 Elliott 6.5 Williams / Sproule 6.5 Campbell-Ryce 7 Maynard 9 Haynes 7 Clarkson 6 Saborio / Akinde / Iwelumo 7 Agyemang 1 Maierhofer / Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mcbcfc Posted May 7, 2010 Report Share Posted May 7, 2010 Gerken 6.5 Henderson 6 Carey 7 Fontaine 7 McCombe 5 Nyatanga 6 Ribeiro 6.5 Orr 6 McAllister 6 Sawyer 6.5 Hartley 7 LJ 6.5 Sno 5 Skuse 7 Elliott 6.5 Williams 5 Sproule 6 Campbell-Ryce 6.5 Maynard 8.5 Haynes 7 Clarkson 6 Saborio 5 Akinde 5 Iwelumo 7 Agyemang 1 Maierhofer 4 as a striker 6 as a keeper (kept a clean sheet) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bristolcitysweden Posted May 7, 2010 Report Share Posted May 7, 2010 Gerken 6 Henderson 6 Collis / Carey 6 Fontaine 6 McCombe 4 Nyatanga 4 Ribeiro 6 Orr 5 B.Wilson / McAllister 4 Sawyer 5 Hartley 6 LJ 4 Sno 5 Skuse 6 Elliott 5 Williams 5 Sproule 4 Campbell-Ryce 4 Maynard 7 Haynes 6 Clarkson 4 Saborio 4 Akinde / Iwelumo 6 Agyemang / Maierhofer / Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
21. Marcham Posted May 7, 2010 Report Share Posted May 7, 2010 Gerken 6 Henderson 6 Collis / Carey 6 Fontaine 6 McCombe 4 Nyatanga 4 Ribeiro 6 Orr 5 B.Wilson / McAllister 4 Sawyer 5 Hartley 6 LJ 4 Sno 5 Skuse 6 Elliott 5 Williams 5 Sproule 4 Campbell-Ryce 4 Maynard 7 Haynes 6 Clarkson 4 Saborio 4 Akinde / Iwelumo 6 Agyemang / Maierhofer / Had a bad day? Or just feeling particularly harsh? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lack of Action Man Posted May 7, 2010 Report Share Posted May 7, 2010 Based upon the players I have seen this season: Gerken 7.5 Henderson (not seen) Carey 6 Fontaine 7.5 McCombe 5 Nyatanga 4 (started well but imo is the destabilizing effect on our defence) Ribeiro 7 (impressive) Orr 7 McAllister 5 Sawyer 6 Hartley 8 LJ 6 Sno 7 Skuse 9 Elliott 5 Sproule 6.5 Campbell-Ryce 5 Maynard 9 Haynes 7 Clarkson 6 Saborio 4 Iwelumo 8 Agyemang 3 Maierhofer 5 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
coxyboy Posted May 7, 2010 Report Share Posted May 7, 2010 Here is my honest opinion Gerken 8 Henderson 7 Collis / Carey 7 Fontaine 6 McCombe 4 Nyatanga 6 Ribeiro 7 Orr 6 B.Wilson / McAllister 5 Sawyer 8 Hartley 7 LJ 1 Sno 4 Skuse 8 Elliott 7 Williams / Sproule 7 Campbell-Ryce 7 Maynard 10 Haynes 8 Clarkson 4 Saborio 2 Akinde 8 Iwelumo 9 Agyemang 2 Maierhofer 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BITW Posted May 7, 2010 Report Share Posted May 7, 2010 Gerken 6 Henderson 7 Carey 6 Fontaine 7 McCombe Nyatanga 6 Ribeiro 7.5 Orr 6.5 McAllister 6 Sawyer 7 Hartley 8 LJ 6 Sno 6.5 Skuse 7.5 Elliott 6.5 Williams ??? Barely played? Sproule 6 Campbell-Ryce 7.5 Maynard 9.5 Haynes 8 Clarkson 6.5 Saborio 4 Akinde 4 Iwelumo 7.5 Agyemang -1 Maierhofe 10 for his goalkeeping Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Always Believesham Posted May 7, 2010 Report Share Posted May 7, 2010 Gerken 6 (Shot stopping 8, Catching 6, Communication/Awareness of defense 4) Henderson 6.5 (Shot stopping 7, Catching 7, Communication/Awareness of defence 6) Collis - gone Carey 6 - started at 8 deteriorated to around 5 Fontaine 7 - didn't live up to first two championship seasons, communication difficulties with Gerken let him down McCombe / - I feel i was too critical of Mcombe as he played in games we did well in aswell as badly Nyatanga - range from 6 to 8 ... showed great potential at times but also had trouble communicating with keeper Ribeiro 8 - put his heart and sole into every match he's played, knew what his capabilities are and listens to leaders on the pitch even when they judged it wrong Orr 7 - always a high energy player, offering something on the wing all season, improved his attacking play aswell as upping his defensive play B.Wilson / McAllister 5 Sawyer 8 - The only defensive player not afraid to put the ball out, getting rid when needed Hartley 6-8 - Showed great experience, scored great goals but tired LJ / Sno 5 - didn't live up to potential and good reports Skuse 9 - put his all in, best midfielder of the season<br>Elliott 6-7 - like fontaine didn't live up to the hype of his first 2 seasons Williams / Sproule / Campbell-Ryce 6 - not a fan of a right footer on the left (being a left footed left sided player often ousted for these players) but he worked hard to make himself an important member of the squad and added to his crossing by "going round the outside" towards the end of the season Maynard 9 - Created himself some great goals and recovered from a dry spell very well, topped off with blackpool goal Haynes 7-8 - Improved over the season Clarkson 6 - not given the opportunity to perform Saborio 6 - showed great potential couldn't live up to it Akinde 7 - really wants to prove himself at this level Iwelumo used us as a step up to wolves team one month not long enough Agyemang 5 - didn't have desired impact, tried to work his way into the team but wasn't up to standard Maierhofer 4 - didn't have desired impact, wasn't fit enough Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
miketh2nd Posted May 8, 2010 Report Share Posted May 8, 2010 Gerken 6.5 Henderson 6 Collis / Carey 6,5 Fontaine 7 McCombe 5 Nyatanga 6- Ribeiro 8 Orr 6.5 B.Wilson / McAllister 5 Sawyer 6.5 Hartley 6 LJ 6 Sno 6 Skuse 8.5 Elliott 6.5 Williams / Sproule 6 Campbell-Ryce 7.5 Maynard 9 Haynes 7 Clarkson 6,5 Saborio 5 Akinde / Iwelumo 8 Agyemang / Maierhofer / Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dan Robin Posted May 9, 2010 Author Report Share Posted May 9, 2010 Agyemang -1 He would be proud of this mark Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
cidercity1987 Posted May 9, 2010 Report Share Posted May 9, 2010 Skuse and Maynard stand out as making contributions worth 8 or 9 this season. Everyone else deserves a 6 or 7 except Agyemang who just stood out for his weight. 5. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Plimsolface Posted May 9, 2010 Report Share Posted May 9, 2010 Gerken 7 Henderson 5 Collis / Carey 7 Fontaine 8 McCombe 4 Nyatanga 5.5 Ribeiro 8 Orr 8 B.Wilson / McAllister 4 Sawyer 6 Hartley 7.5 LJ 5 Sno 6 Skuse 8.5 Elliott 7.5 Williams 4 Sproule 7 Campbell-Ryce 7 Maynard 9 Haynes 8 Clarkson 6.5 Saborio 4 Akinde 4 Iwelumo 8 Agyemang 0 Maierhofer 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Red_Mat Posted May 10, 2010 Report Share Posted May 10, 2010 ah, thought this was gonna be a thread about spotting players shopping! Not just players...but Marks and Spencers' players... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.