Jump to content

Welcome to One Team in Bristol - Bristol City Forums

Welcome to One Team in Bristol - Bristol City Forums, like most online communities you must register to view or post in our community, but don't worry this is a simple free process that requires minimal information for you to signup. Be a part of One Team in Bristol - Bristol City Forums by signing in or creating an account.

  • Start new topics and reply to others
  • Full access to all forums (not all viewable as guest)
  • Subscribe to topics and forums to get email updates
  • Get your own profile page and make new friends
  • Send personal messages to other members.
  • Support OTIB with a premium membership

Aberdeen Pete's Dad

Seen it all before

Recommended Posts

Some things never change. I have heard it all before. LJ out. Sod out. McInnes out. Doherty out Houghton out . Osman out . Dicks out .  Whichever manager we have ever had will never take us to the promised land, apart from Dicks of whom the same was said before he did take us up ( and down again). So all those predictions over the years have proved to be correct.

We ( indeed the whole of the West Country ) has had a total of 4 years of top division football since the First World War - FACT 

Every team  except Millwall and Barnsley have spent more seasons in the top division than we have in the last 100 years- FACT

Every team in the championship except Preston and Brentford have been in the top division since we were last there - FACT

Plymouth is the biggest city never to have played in the top division- FACT

Exeter is the biggest city never to have played in the second tier - FACT

Why do we expect anything different ? Look at our fixtures and compare them with 50 years ago.- Blackburn Cardiff Hull Huddersfield Preston Millwall Charlton Middlesbrough Sheffield Wednesday Birmingham etc etc - pretty well the same. Of course, there are some teams in the Premier League who are smaller than us - Bournemouth ( definitely) Brighton Watford ( arguably) and good luck to them, , but in a few years they will come down again like Swansea and Wigan have done. Of course, for every one of those, there is a Sunderland Ipswich Coventry or Bolton who are below their “ natural” place in the order of things , but they will all come back - eventually. 

We all hope to get to the Premier League, at least for a while, ( although if/ when we do I hope we don’t go down 3 seasons in a row like the last time) , but it isn’t easy playing in a division when the great majority of teams are unquestionably bigger than us, and nearly all of  whom have a greater history. Bournemouth and Brighton have shown that it can be done.

What is it that causes us ( and all West Country teams) to apparently underachieve ? . Players come and go. Managers come and go. Directors come and go. Owners come and go, but for the most part things stay the same.

The only thing that never changes are the fans. However, the majority of those who are quick to come out and criticise after a few bad results, but remain quiet when the team are winning, refuse to even consider the possibility that their anxiety, negativity and pessimism may be  a factor in what many perceive to be the club’s chronic underachievement over decades. They are affronted they anyone should even suggest that this might be so.

It is funny how occasionally things from one’s childhood occasionally stick in the memory. I remember it clearly . Coventry at home in January 1967. We drew 2-2 with a team which won the Second Division that season. Some fans were moaning like they do now about City’s lack of achievement. I can clearly remember saying to my mate that if City were ever to win the First Division (as unlikely then as it is now) , some fans would say that this team will never win the European Cup !

Some things never change. I have heard it all before.

 

  • Like 9
  • Aubergine 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, Aberdeen Pete's Dad said:

Some things never change. I have heard it all before. LJ out. Sod out. McInnes out. Doherty out Houghton out . Osman out . Dicks out .  Whichever manager we have ever had will never take us to the promised land, apart from Dicks of whom the same was said before he did take us up ( and down again). So all those predictions over the years have proved to be correct.

We ( indeed the whole of the West Country ) has had a total of 4 years of top division football since the First World War - FACT 

Every team  except Millwall and Barnsley have spent more seasons in the top division than we have in the last 100 years- FACT

Every team in the championship except Preston and Brentford have been in the top division since we were last there - FACT

Plymouth is the biggest city never to have played in the top division- FACT

Exeter is the biggest city never to have played in the second tier - FACT

Why do we expect anything different ? Look at our fixtures and compare them with 50 years ago.- Blackburn Cardiff Hull Huddersfield Preston Millwall Charlton Middlesbrough Sheffield Wednesday Birmingham etc etc - pretty well the same. Of course, there are some teams in the Premier League who are smaller than us - Bournemouth ( definitely) Brighton Watford ( arguably) and good luck to them, , but in a few years they will come down again like Swansea and Wigan have done. Of course, for every one of those, there is a Sunderland Ipswich Coventry or Bolton who are below their “ natural” place in the order of things , but they will all come back - eventually. 

We all hope to get to the Premier League, at least for a while, ( although if/ when we do I hope we don’t go down 3 seasons in a row like the last time) , but it isn’t easy playing in a division when the great majority of teams are unquestionably bigger than us, and nearly all of  whom have a greater history. Bournemouth and Brighton have shown that it can be done.

What is it that causes us ( and all West Country teams) to apparently underachieve ? . Players come and go. Managers come and go. Directors come and go. Owners come and go, but for the most part things stay the same.

The only thing that never changes are the fans. However, the majority of those who are quick to come out and criticise after a few bad results, but remain quiet when the team are winning, refuse to even consider the possibility that their anxiety, negativity and pessimism may be  a factor in what many perceive to be the club’s chronic underachievement over decades. They are affronted they anyone should even suggest that this might be so.

It is funny how occasionally things from one’s childhood occasionally stick in the memory. I remember it clearly . Coventry at home in January 1967. We drew 2-2 with a team which won the Second Division that season. Some fans were moaning like they do now about City’s lack of achievement. I can clearly remember saying to my mate that if City were ever to win the First Division (as unlikely then as it is now) , some fans would say that this team will never win the European Cup !

Some things never change. I have heard it all before.

 

Merry Christmas LEE, close door on your way OUT

  • Haha 1
  • Aubergine 1
  • Rovers 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 minutes ago, Aberdeen Pete's Dad said:

Some things never change. I have heard it all before. LJ out. Sod out. McInnes out. Doherty out Houghton out . Osman out . Dicks out .  Whichever manager we have ever had will never take us to the promised land, apart from Dicks of whom the same was said before he did take us up ( and down again). So all those predictions over the years have proved to be correct.

We ( indeed the whole of the West Country ) has had a total of 4 years of top division football since the First World War - FACT 

Every team  except Millwall and Barnsley have spent more seasons in the top division than we have in the last 100 years- FACT

Every team in the championship except Preston and Brentford have been in the top division since we were last there - FACT

Plymouth is the biggest city never to have played in the top division- FACT

Exeter is the biggest city never to have played in the second tier - FACT

Why do we expect anything different ? Look at our fixtures and compare them with 50 years ago.- Blackburn Cardiff Hull Huddersfield Preston Millwall Charlton Middlesbrough Sheffield Wednesday Birmingham etc etc - pretty well the same. Of course, there are some teams in the Premier League who are smaller than us - Bournemouth ( definitely) Brighton Watford ( arguably) and good luck to them, , but in a few years they will come down again like Swansea and Wigan have done. Of course, for every one of those, there is a Sunderland Ipswich Coventry or Bolton who are below their “ natural” place in the order of things , but they will all come back - eventually. 

We all hope to get to the Premier League, at least for a while, ( although if/ when we do I hope we don’t go down 3 seasons in a row like the last time) , but it isn’t easy playing in a division when the great majority of teams are unquestionably bigger than us, and nearly all of  whom have a greater history. Bournemouth and Brighton have shown that it can be done.

What is it that causes us ( and all West Country teams) to apparently underachieve ? . Players come and go. Managers come and go. Directors come and go. Owners come and go, but for the most part things stay the same.

The only thing that never changes are the fans. However, the majority of those who are quick to come out and criticise after a few bad results, but remain quiet when the team are winning, refuse to even consider the possibility that their anxiety, negativity and pessimism may be  a factor in what many perceive to be the club’s chronic underachievement over decades. They are affronted they anyone should even suggest that this might be so.

It is funny how occasionally things from one’s childhood occasionally stick in the memory. I remember it clearly . Coventry at home in January 1967. We drew 2-2 with a team which won the Second Division that season. Some fans were moaning like they do now about City’s lack of achievement. I can clearly remember saying to my mate that if City were ever to win the First Division (as unlikely then as it is now) , some fans would say that this team will never win the European Cup !

Some things never change. I have heard it all before.

 

You're absolutely right. I remember when AD was in charge and the team struggling in Div 2 (including losing at Charlton when they were bottom of the league by a mile) and the fans then were just the same, luckily the board at the time took no notice and we had the best seasons in the club's latter day history. Groundhog day.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Biggest city never to have won the top league, Bristol.

Biggest city never to have won the FA cup, Bristol.

Biggest city never to have even been in the Prem, Bristol.

Why should we always accept mediocrity?

 

  • Like 13

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 minutes ago, ashton_fan said:

You're absolutely right. I remember when AD was in charge and the team struggling in Div 2 (including losing at Charlton when they were bottom of the league by a mile) and the fans then were just the same, luckily the board at the time took no notice and we had the best seasons in the club's latter day history. Groundhog day.

Alan Dicks built a side, he had a plan.

He didn’t have millions of pounds to play with, he didn’t change the team on a weekly basis, he didn’t buy in about 50 players and still not be satisfied, and he didn’t moan about lack of leaders having signed those 50 players himself.

 

  • Like 3
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
31 minutes ago, Aberdeen Pete's Dad said:

Some things never change. I have heard it all before. LJ out. Sod out. McInnes out. Doherty out Houghton out . Osman out . Dicks out .  Whichever manager we have ever had will never take us to the promised land, apart from Dicks of whom the same was said before he did take us up ( and down again). So all those predictions over the years have proved to be correct.

We ( indeed the whole of the West Country ) has had a total of 4 years of top division football since the First World War - FACT 

Every team  except Millwall and Barnsley have spent more seasons in the top division than we have in the last 100 years- FACT

Every team in the championship except Preston and Brentford have been in the top division since we were last there - FACT

Plymouth is the biggest city never to have played in the top division- FACT

Exeter is the biggest city never to have played in the second tier - FACT

Why do we expect anything different ? Look at our fixtures and compare them with 50 years ago.- Blackburn Cardiff Hull Huddersfield Preston Millwall Charlton Middlesbrough Sheffield Wednesday Birmingham etc etc - pretty well the same. Of course, there are some teams in the Premier League who are smaller than us - Bournemouth ( definitely) Brighton Watford ( arguably) and good luck to them, , but in a few years they will come down again like Swansea and Wigan have done. Of course, for every one of those, there is a Sunderland Ipswich Coventry or Bolton who are below their “ natural” place in the order of things , but they will all come back - eventually. 

We all hope to get to the Premier League, at least for a while, ( although if/ when we do I hope we don’t go down 3 seasons in a row like the last time) , but it isn’t easy playing in a division when the great majority of teams are unquestionably bigger than us, and nearly all of  whom have a greater history. Bournemouth and Brighton have shown that it can be done.

What is it that causes us ( and all West Country teams) to apparently underachieve ? . Players come and go. Managers come and go. Directors come and go. Owners come and go, but for the most part things stay the same.

The only thing that never changes are the fans. However, the majority of those who are quick to come out and criticise after a few bad results, but remain quiet when the team are winning, refuse to even consider the possibility that their anxiety, negativity and pessimism may be  a factor in what many perceive to be the club’s chronic underachievement over decades. They are affronted they anyone should even suggest that this might be so.

It is funny how occasionally things from one’s childhood occasionally stick in the memory. I remember it clearly . Coventry at home in January 1967. We drew 2-2 with a team which won the Second Division that season. Some fans were moaning like they do now about City’s lack of achievement. I can clearly remember saying to my mate that if City were ever to win the First Division (as unlikely then as it is now) , some fans would say that this team will never win the European Cup !

Some things never change. I have heard it all before.

 

Top post 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
24 minutes ago, cidercity1987 said:

Biggest city never to have won the top league, Bristol.

Biggest city never to have won the FA cup, Bristol.

Biggest city never to have even been in the Prem, Bristol.

Why should we always accept mediocrity?

 

It’s what we do best .:yes:

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Jesus wept. This is pathetic.

Why do we bother turning up then?

Quick to come out and criticise? It's 40 years since we last enjoyed Christmas in the top flight! That's my adult lifetime.

 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The reason why the West teams are ‘soft’ is that we haven’t got a ruthless streak. We’re happy to be also-rans. 

Worked in various places in the UK. Spent most of my time in the South West telling people that  ‘it’s ok’ simply isn’t good enough. 

 

 We need a ‘ruthless’ manager. Someone who’ll sort out the huge number of softies in our squad from Day 1. Needs to be clever as ‘old school’ managers don’t seem to be acceptable to the snowflakes nowadays... but he needs to get performances out of our literally dozens of ‘also rans’ that we’ve imported or developed. If they don’t respond and perform just kick them out the Club. They’re like a cancer that spreads and affect others. 

Cotts nearly sorted it, but for whatever reason lost the support of SL - which effectively cut him off at the knees.

Interesting isn’t it, 4 years on and who’d bet against the Cotts tightly knit TEAM of winners beating any of about 10 teams LJ could put out from his squad. 

  • Hmmm 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This in spades....we're a mid table championship who go on streaky winning and losing runs. We're not consistent and therefore not actually good enough to be promoted.

I had an offer of a free ticket to the Luton game. I turned it down. I go to be entertained and not bored out of my mind. The football is turgid, devoid of ideas and we can't defend or attack. 

With the current squad, we can be entertaining, but we set up to mitigate the opposition, rather than play to our strengths. What is wrong with TRYING TO WIN? 

The mindset is wrong and everything comes from mindset - the players, the fans, the atmosphere. Until this changes, we'll keep losing. 

  • Like 3
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Portland Bill said:

Alan Dicks built a side, he had a plan.

He didn’t have millions of pounds to play with, he didn’t change the team on a weekly basis, he didn’t buy in about 50 players and still not be satisfied, and he didn’t moan about lack of leaders having signed those 50 players himself.

 

AD didn't have millions to play with (no manager in Div 2 did in those days) but he wasn't forced to sell his best players either. I'm sure he did moan about the players on occasions although in those days there wasn't much interaction with the Press and there wasn't any internet, and certainly before the promotion season he did make regular changes to the team introducing youngsters and playing experienced players where required as well as dropping players who didn't perform.

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, RedRock said:

The reason why the West teams are ‘soft’ is that we haven’t got a ruthless streak. We’re happy to be also-rans. 

Worked in various places in the UK. Spent most of my time in the South West telling people that  ‘it’s ok’ simply isn’t good enough. 

 

 We need a ‘ruthless’ manager. Someone who’ll sort out the huge number of softies in our squad from Day 1. Needs to be clever as ‘old school’ managers don’t seem to be acceptable to the snowflakes nowadays... but he needs to get performances out of our literally dozens of ‘also rans’ that we’ve imported or developed. If they don’t respond and perform just kick them out the Club. They’re like a cancer that spreads and affect others. 

Cotts nearly sorted it, but for whatever reason lost the support of SL - which effectively cut him off at the knees.

Interesting isn’t it, 4 years on and who’d bet against the Cotts tightly knit TEAM of winners beating any of about 10 teams LJ could put out from his squad. 

Possibly. Possibly..

I don't necessarily agree on the also-rans label. These are players from a decent level, a decent track record. Internationals in okay sides, decent Leagues,  in the case of Massengo from an excellent academy in Monaco- if you doubt my view, go away and research these players. 

Old school managers often fail. Game has changed,  life has changed. I give you Roy Keane! 

If they're as poor as you suggest, kicking them out is easier said than done. For that you surely need to find wiling buyers or loan interest.

If you mean sack, it's brave but it'd be a massive FFP hit or could,  and possibly would damage us in the medium term, reputationally. Would players be interested in coming to a club with a big sacking culture, in 2019? On tg the FFP point, sacking would surely entail paying up contracts, plus the remaining amortisation would come off the books in that season, we'd run up enormous losses surely, FFP says hi! Also we'd lose sale, resale value.

Really though, really? We were conceding a lot of goals, we were losing a lot. Nobody can say for sure whether Cotts could've saved us, but I'm unsure. Certainly would question whether Cotts 2015 side beats LJ as of now side. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, cidercity1987 said:

Biggest city never to have won the top league, Bristol.

Biggest city never to have won the FA cup, Bristol.

Biggest city never to have even been in the Prem, Bristol.

Why should we always accept mediocrity?

 

Biggest UK city never to have had a successful rock band...

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, David Brent said:

Thanks for summing up football fans. Our club is no different.

Yep the sooner we are back in league 1 and become a big fish because we are wasting our time in the championship Bristol really is a football backwater 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, Mr Popodopolous said:

Possibly. Possibly..

I don't necessarily agree on the also-rans label. These are players from a decent level, a decent track record. Internationals in okay sides, decent Leagues,  in the case of Massengo from an excellent academy in Monaco- if you doubt my view, go away and research these players. 

Old school managers often fail. Game has changed,  life has changed. I give you Roy Keane! 

If they're as poor as you suggest, kicking them out is easier said than done. For that you surely need to find wiling buyers or loan interest.

If you mean sack, it's brave but it'd be a massive FFP hit or could,  and possibly would damage us in the medium term, reputationally. Would players be interested in coming to a club with a big sacking culture, in 2019? On tg the FFP point, sacking would surely entail paying up contracts, plus the remaining amortisation would come off the books in that season, we'd run up enormous losses surely, FFP says hi! Also we'd lose sale, resale value.

Really though, really? We were conceding a lot of goals, we were losing a lot. Nobody can say for sure whether Cotts could've saved us, but I'm unsure. Certainly would question whether Cotts 2015 side beats LJ as of now side. 

I would be surprised if LJ’s contract included full pay-out of remaining years....SL got caught by that with Cotts.  But you are right, there is a cost to sacking, even more so if assistants go with him.  Then you have cost of recruiting too, maybe compensation to club you poach their manager from.  And he’ll want some money in January too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 minutes ago, Davefevs said:

I would be surprised if LJ’s contract included full pay-out of remaining years....SL got caught by that with Cotts.  But you are right, there is a cost to sacking, even more so if assistants go with him.  Then you have cost of recruiting too, maybe compensation to club you poach their manager from.  And he’ll want some money in January too.

I think Moor 2 Sea and me were cross purposes a bit. 'If they don't perform just kick then out the club'.

I assumed that post was referring to players- something that'd be hugely costly, unfeasible if the poster meant sack and a major FFP hit, to say nothing of value lost etc.

Agree on LJ,  3 years would be fairly unlikely given Cotts.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 minutes ago, Davefevs said:

I would be surprised if LJ’s contract included full pay-out of remaining years....SL got caught by that with Cotts.  But you are right, there is a cost to sacking, even more so if assistants go with him.  Then you have cost of recruiting too, maybe compensation to club you poach their manager from.  And he’ll want some money in January too.

This is why I strongly suspect we will be with LJ until the end of the season, unless the slide continues until March and relegation threatens.

Would've expected our CEO to include a break-clause in the contract relating to performance. If he doesn’t meet the target of top 6 he will be out at the end of season without us having to pay-up his full contract. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, Mr Popodopolous said:

I think Moor 2 Sea and me were cross purposes a bit. 'If they don't perform just kick then out the club'.

I assumed that post was referring to players- something that'd be hugely costly, unfeasible if the poster meant sack and a major FFP hit, to say nothing of value lost etc.

Agree on LJ,  3 years would be fairly unlikely given Cotts.

No. You were correct in your first assumption. I did mean the players. 

‘Kick them out’ I agree could well be difficult for some (we did manage to persuade Cardiff to take Tomlin though). But you can freeze them out, to avoid the bad apples infecting the whole squad. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Aberdeen Pete's Dad said:

Some things never change. I have heard it all before. LJ out. Sod out. McInnes out. Doherty out Houghton out . Osman out . Dicks out .  Whichever manager we have ever had will never take us to the promised land, apart from Dicks of whom the same was said before he did take us up ( and down again). So all those predictions over the years have proved to be correct.

We ( indeed the whole of the West Country ) has had a total of 4 years of top division football since the First World War - FACT 

Every team  except Millwall and Barnsley have spent more seasons in the top division than we have in the last 100 years- FACT

Every team in the championship except Preston and Brentford have been in the top division since we were last there - FACT

Plymouth is the biggest city never to have played in the top division- FACT

Exeter is the biggest city never to have played in the second tier - FACT

Why do we expect anything different ? Look at our fixtures and compare them with 50 years ago.- Blackburn Cardiff Hull Huddersfield Preston Millwall Charlton Middlesbrough Sheffield Wednesday Birmingham etc etc - pretty well the same. Of course, there are some teams in the Premier League who are smaller than us - Bournemouth ( definitely) Brighton Watford ( arguably) and good luck to them, , but in a few years they will come down again like Swansea and Wigan have done. Of course, for every one of those, there is a Sunderland Ipswich Coventry or Bolton who are below their “ natural” place in the order of things , but they will all come back - eventually. 

We all hope to get to the Premier League, at least for a while, ( although if/ when we do I hope we don’t go down 3 seasons in a row like the last time) , but it isn’t easy playing in a division when the great majority of teams are unquestionably bigger than us, and nearly all of  whom have a greater history. Bournemouth and Brighton have shown that it can be done.

What is it that causes us ( and all West Country teams) to apparently underachieve ? . Players come and go. Managers come and go. Directors come and go. Owners come and go, but for the most part things stay the same.

The only thing that never changes are the fans. However, the majority of those who are quick to come out and criticise after a few bad results, but remain quiet when the team are winning, refuse to even consider the possibility that their anxiety, negativity and pessimism may be  a factor in what many perceive to be the club’s chronic underachievement over decades. They are affronted they anyone should even suggest that this might be so.

It is funny how occasionally things from one’s childhood occasionally stick in the memory. I remember it clearly . Coventry at home in January 1967. We drew 2-2 with a team which won the Second Division that season. Some fans were moaning like they do now about City’s lack of achievement. I can clearly remember saying to my mate that if City were ever to win the First Division (as unlikely then as it is now) , some fans would say that this team will never win the European Cup !

Some things never change. I have heard it all before.

 

Coventry went up in '68. They had 33 - thirty ******* three! - unbroken seasons of top class football, winning, brilliantly, and famously, an FA Cup final along the way.

Prior to this, they had no history of top flight football. 

And their crowds were shite for about 30 of those seasons. Pitiful. Cov had nothing over us in terms of crowds and income and resources and yet they managed more than 8 times the amount of top level football. Would it be ok with you to have a problem with that?

Meanwhile, we - with a greater history than Cov - managed four years at the top, three of which were pretty grim struggle against relegation  (and not a whiff of any FA cup glory). And then we collapsed like a pack of bloody cards, spending years of mediocrity amongst the likes of Walsall, Gillingham, Rovers and so on.

And you wonder about the attitude - and the bitterness - of the crowd at AG? 

 

We have been shite, and have hugely underperformed, as a club, for decades. SL has done much to try and  correct or change this, and he has much to do still, by the looks of it.

The people you cite "moaning" at AG were paying money to be there and keeping the club going, unlike most people in Bristol. 

It really could have been so much better; up until parachute payments we had more than enough of what you need to be a top flight club, but it hasn't happened here (while happening in other very similar size clubs around the country, and many smaller, including some in football "backwaters" and at clubs with no previous top class history).

As I see it, we have every reason to grumble about the people that have run the club and the level of football they have delivered for the people of Bristol. 

 

 

  • Like 2
  • Hmmm 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

33 years of unbeaten top division football would do me nicely, like Coventry who went up in 1967,  especially if it included an FACup win and a season of European football (would have been two were it not foe English clubs ban).

Of course, as you say , we have underperformed for decades. Of course, every club’s fans pay to watch their team and can criticise if they want, but in any one season only 20 teams can play in the Premier League. No one has a right to be there. The moaning of some fans when their team does not make the top 4 to play in the Champions League makes me laugh/ sick.

All I am saying is that fans should consider whether their anxiety and negativity which has gone on for ever,  is a reason why we are an underachieving club. After all, the last 2-3 years have been one of the better spells in the last 100 years - perhaps only our golden era of the 1970s has been better - it was the only time that we have managed more than 6 seasons without being relegated- if we stay up this year it will be our 6 th season. Actually, thinking about it, every time we have managed to stay in the second tier for more than 6 seasons we have gone up shortly afterwards. Perhaps, hope is round the corner !

if Coventry can stay up for 33 years so can we.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, Aberdeen Pete's Dad said:

 

 

 

6 hours ago, Aberdeen Pete's Dad said:

We ( indeed the whole of the West Country ) has had a total of 4 years of top division football since the First World War - FACT

Swindon not part of the West Country?  Oh, you have said that is a FACT, so I will bow to your superior "FACT-awareness" (only being pedantic - FACT!!)😀

Actually, I do agree with quite a bit of what you are saying, I just feel that when someone says "FACT" after their statements it makes me cringe a bit! 

Edited by New Dazzler

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, RedRock said:

This is why I strongly suspect we will be with LJ until the end of the season, unless the slide continues until March and relegation threatens.

Would've expected our CEO to include a break-clause in the contract relating to performance. If he doesn’t meet the target of top 6 he will be out at the end of season without us having to pay-up his full contract. 

I agree with this, didn't Steve Lansdown say that the target this season was top 6? If that doesn't happen then the pressure will be on him to act - maybe!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

LJ is safe until the end of the season whatever the fans may think. However come the end of the season and we don’t have a top 6 or even top half of the table finish then SL’s legendary patience might finally snap.

LJ can moan all he likes about injuries but the reality is that as well as a toothless attack without Afobe, we have a misfiring midfield and a leaky defence, which would have conceded far more but for Bentley’s regular heroics in goal. There must be some deep-seated deficiencies in his coaching, highlighted by yet another bad losing streak. It isn’t just coincidence or bad luck that this keeps happening to him. The players change but the patterns remain the same, which suggests the fault lies with the one constant, the coaching team.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, Aberdeen Pete's Dad said:

Some things never change. I have heard it all before. LJ out. Sod out. McInnes out. Doherty out Houghton out . Osman out . Dicks out .  Whichever manager we have ever had will never take us to the promised land, apart from Dicks of whom the same was said before he did take us up ( and down again). So all those predictions over the years have proved to be correct.

We ( indeed the whole of the West Country ) has had a total of 4 years of top division football since the First World War - FACT 

Every team  except Millwall and Barnsley have spent more seasons in the top division than we have in the last 100 years- FACT

Every team in the championship except Preston and Brentford have been in the top division since we were last there - FACT

Plymouth is the biggest city never to have played in the top division- FACT

Exeter is the biggest city never to have played in the second tier - FACT

Why do we expect anything different ? Look at our fixtures and compare them with 50 years ago.- Blackburn Cardiff Hull Huddersfield Preston Millwall Charlton Middlesbrough Sheffield Wednesday Birmingham etc etc - pretty well the same. Of course, there are some teams in the Premier League who are smaller than us - Bournemouth ( definitely) Brighton Watford ( arguably) and good luck to them, , but in a few years they will come down again like Swansea and Wigan have done. Of course, for every one of those, there is a Sunderland Ipswich Coventry or Bolton who are below their “ natural” place in the order of things , but they will all come back - eventually. 

We all hope to get to the Premier League, at least for a while, ( although if/ when we do I hope we don’t go down 3 seasons in a row like the last time) , but it isn’t easy playing in a division when the great majority of teams are unquestionably bigger than us, and nearly all of  whom have a greater history. Bournemouth and Brighton have shown that it can be done.

What is it that causes us ( and all West Country teams) to apparently underachieve ? . Players come and go. Managers come and go. Directors come and go. Owners come and go, but for the most part things stay the same.

The only thing that never changes are the fans. However, the majority of those who are quick to come out and criticise after a few bad results, but remain quiet when the team are winning, refuse to even consider the possibility that their anxiety, negativity and pessimism may be  a factor in what many perceive to be the club’s chronic underachievement over decades. They are affronted they anyone should even suggest that this might be so.

It is funny how occasionally things from one’s childhood occasionally stick in the memory. I remember it clearly . Coventry at home in January 1967. We drew 2-2 with a team which won the Second Division that season. Some fans were moaning like they do now about City’s lack of achievement. I can clearly remember saying to my mate that if City were ever to win the First Division (as unlikely then as it is now) , some fans would say that this team will never win the European Cup !

Some things never change. I have heard it all before.

 

I don’t think we can ignore the fact that the atmosphere down the gate is shit most of the time and some of the blame lays at the door of us fans.

The team were boo’d off the pitch at half time after 10+ games unbeaten last season which quite frankly is embarrassing. I said last year, you could feel the tension in the crowd and that MUST affect the players etc.

We have expectations above our post at the minute. There’s no problem with wanting more and having ambition but we can’t have a home atmosphere that EXPECTS to win every game. We’ve always created our best atmospheres as underdogs/against the odds (Palace play off, United/Man City at home for example) 

Our home atmosphere is better in a relegation fight than a promotion battle and that needs resolving first and foremost. None of this “the team needs to give us something to cheer about” shit, we need to get behind the team.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 hours ago, Aberdeen Pete's Dad said:

Some things never change. I have heard it all before. LJ out. Sod out. McInnes out. Doherty out Houghton out . Osman out . Dicks out .  Whichever manager we have ever had will never take us to the promised land, apart from Dicks of whom the same was said before he did take us up ( and down again). So all those predictions over the years have proved to be correct.

We ( indeed the whole of the West Country ) has had a total of 4 years of top division football since the First World War - FACT 

Every team  except Millwall and Barnsley have spent more seasons in the top division than we have in the last 100 years- FACT

Every team in the championship except Preston and Brentford have been in the top division since we were last there - FACT

 

You could add to that:

Most expensive Bristol City squad ever assembled - FACT

which has undoubtedly increased expectations.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree it is irritating when someone states FACT. That is why I said it. It is particularly irritating when people give opinion as fact eg Johnson is crap - FACT. I am taking the mickey out of them. At least my facts are facts !

It is true most expensive Bristol City ever assembled -FACT

One final FACT. Most expensive Bristol City sales in any 2 yr period . More than the cost of assembling the current squad.

Happy New Year

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, Aberdeen Pete's Dad said:

If Coventry can stay up for 33 years so can we.

After going up in '68, Coventry went 50 years without finishing above 5th in any division. Bit turgid that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
11 hours ago, ashton_fan said:

AD didn't have millions to play with (no manager in Div 2 did in those days) but he wasn't forced to sell his best players either. I'm sure he did moan about the players on occasions although in those days there wasn't much interaction with the Press and there wasn't any internet, and certainly before the promotion season he did make regular changes to the team introducing youngsters and playing experienced players where required as well as dropping players who didn't perform.

Nor were there parachute payments distorting the competition. The financial playing field was far more level.

Of course you are right about keeping key players. If we had 2 players wanted by Arsenal now, as we did then, we would sell like a shot.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
23 minutes ago, Mad Cyril said:

After going up in '68, Coventry went 50 years without finishing above 5th in any division. Bit turgid that.

But finished top ten in the country several times - a 6th place finish, 7th twice, nine seasons better than our best finish of 13th in 78/9 - in those 33 seasons at the top and they won the cup, making their mark upon the national football consciousness something we have never done and never will outside the top division. 

If you are going to be "turgid," then be so at the highest level possible against the best in the land and for clubs like Cov and us there is no shame in that. While Cov were being "turgid" at the top, we were often being crap in Division Three.

Our four seasons from 76 - 80 are remembered fondly by us, but to the rest of the country we were generally pretty "turgid" too, if we are remembered for it at all. In truth, we were unremarkable and largely forgettable to the rest of football. 

We did gain some national notice shortly after that time though, between 80 and 82.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
28 minutes ago, Aberdeen Pete's Dad said:

I agree it is irritating when someone states FACT. That is why I said it. It is particularly irritating when people give opinion as fact eg Johnson is crap - FACT. I am taking the mickey out of them. At least my facts are facts !

It is true most expensive Bristol City ever assembled -FACT

One final FACT. Most expensive Bristol City sales in any 2 yr period . More than the cost of assembling the current squad.

Happy New Year

That's also true, but of those sales only one was a player purchased by the current manager, the others were inherited.

Never before, for example, has Bristol City had the luxury of having an £8 million player on the bench, or another example, a £2 million player out on loan for 3 seasons, or another example, a £5 million centre forward who was not a first choice until our loan player was injured, or another example a £3 million goalkeeper, or another example an £8 million centre half with a £4 million centre half not a first choice selection, and so on - all FACTS of course and says to me, looking at the teams above us and their spending power, we are currently slightly under achieving. 

Having said that, 4 games ago we were currently in the play off positions with very few if any suggesting the manager should be sacked. For me the jury is still out on Johnson - which is an improvement on what I thought when he was first appointed -  but even I accept it would be absurd to suggest sacking Johnson on the strength of just 4 games.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Aberdeen Pete's Dad said:

33 years of unbeaten top division football would do me nicely, like Coventry who went up in 1967,  especially if it included an FACup win and a season of European football (would have been two were it not foe English clubs ban).

Of course, as you say , we have underperformed for decades. Of course, every club’s fans pay to watch their team and can criticise if they want, but in any one season only 20 teams can play in the Premier League. No one has a right to be there. The moaning of some fans when their team does not make the top 4 to play in the Champions League makes me laugh/ sick.

All I am saying is that fans should consider whether their anxiety and negativity which has gone on for ever,  is a reason why we are an underachieving club. After all, the last 2-3 years have been one of the better spells in the last 100 years - perhaps only our golden era of the 1970s has been better - it was the only time that we have managed more than 6 seasons without being relegated- if we stay up this year it will be our 6 th season. Actually, thinking about it, every time we have managed to stay in the second tier for more than 6 seasons we have gone up shortly afterwards. Perhaps, hope is round the corner !

if Coventry can stay up for 33 years so can we.

Yes, the crowd is too negative, or not encouraging enough. It would be much better if we collectively encouraged the team more and provided a more positive environment for them to go about their work.

But looking at our long long history of under achievement and disappointment when compared to similar sized clubs it really is no great surprise to me that we are lacking in belief and positivity and that the crowd isn't what we would like it to be.

However, to believe that this is the reason why we have been so poor and under achieving for so long is missing the point to my mind, and letting those with the ability and power to direct our fortunes off the hook.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...