Jump to content
IGNORED

Player Ratings


Davefevs

Recommended Posts

Tough old afternoon:

Bentley: 8 kept us in the game (MOTM)

Vyner: 6 okay until we got stretched

Moore: 5 lucky boy not to see red

Rowe: 7 my pick of the outfield starters

Hunt: 5 bit sloppy today

O’Dowda: 6 bit “pretty” at times but ok

Nagy: 6 showed some nice touches to break the lines

Paterson: 5 quiet

Dasilva: 6 okay

Diedhiou: 5 not involved enough but little service

Semenyo: 5 not quite at it today

Subs:

Wells: looked really sharp and up for it - goal too

Martin: 6 brought a target

Brunt: 5 okay in ball, poor w/o it

Massengo: -

Edwards: -

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, Bassomylord said:

Bentley 8

Hunt 6

Vyner 7

Moore 5

Rowe 6

Dasilva 6

Paterson 5

Nagy 7

O dowda 6

Semenyo 5

Diedhiou 3

Was about to post my scores but mine are exactly the same.

(I may have given Diedhiou a 1 or 2 for turning up)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

21 minutes ago, Davefevs said:

Tough old afternoon:

Bentley: 8 kept us in the game (MOTM)

Vyner: 6 okay until we got stretched

Moore: 5 lucky boy not to see red

Rowe: 7 my pick of the outfield starters

Hunt: 5 bit sloppy today

O’Dowda: 6 bit “pretty” at times but ok

Nagy: 6 showed some nice touches to break the lines

Paterson: 5 quiet

Dasilva: 6 okay

Diedhiou: 5 not involved enough but little service

Semenyo: 5 not quite at it today

Subs:

Wells: looked really sharp and up for it - goal too

Martin: 6 brought a target

Brunt: 5 okay in ball, poor w/o it

Massengo: -

Edwards: -

I think your ratings are fair. Perhaps it's time for Holden to go and get the tombola from Johnson. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

29 minutes ago, Davefevs said:

Tough old afternoon:

Bentley: 8 kept us in the game (MOTM)

Vyner: 6 okay until we got stretched

Moore: 5 lucky boy not to see red

Rowe: 7 my pick of the outfield starters

Hunt: 5 bit sloppy today

O’Dowda: 6 bit “pretty” at times but ok

Nagy: 6 showed some nice touches to break the lines

Paterson: 5 quiet

Dasilva: 6 okay

Diedhiou: 5 not involved enough but little service

Semenyo: 5 not quite at it today

Subs:

Wells: looked really sharp and up for it - goal too

Martin: 6 brought a target

Brunt: 5 okay in ball, poor w/o it

Massengo: -

Edwards: -

How the hell do you give Patterson 5, surely you missed out a minus? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

47 minutes ago, Davefevs said:

Tough old afternoon:

Bentley: 8 kept us in the game (MOTM)

Vyner: 6 okay until we got stretched

Moore: 5 lucky boy not to see red

Rowe: 7 my pick of the outfield starters

Hunt: 5 bit sloppy today

O’Dowda: 6 bit “pretty” at times but ok

Nagy: 6 showed some nice touches to break the lines

Paterson: 5 quiet

Dasilva: 6 okay

Diedhiou: 5 not involved enough but little service

Semenyo: 5 not quite at it today

Subs:

Wells: looked really sharp and up for it - goal too

Martin: 6 brought a target

Brunt: 5 okay in ball, poor w/o it

Massengo: -

Edwards: -

Agree with most of your calls, but would make Paterson and Diedhiou 3s, both were really poor. If we are going to play 3-5-2, we MUST start with Martin up top. His ability to hold onto the ball and bring others into play is crucial. Fammy just does not do this. Paterson needs to dropped after that non-performance, he needs a kick up the arse at times. COD, apart from one poor cross early on, did much better today. I'd start Bakinson, Nagy & COD in CM against QPR.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Davefevs said:

Tough old afternoon:

Bentley: 8 kept us in the game (MOTM)

Vyner: 6 okay until we got stretched

Moore: 5 lucky boy not to see red

Rowe: 7 my pick of the outfield starters

Hunt: 5 bit sloppy today

O’Dowda: 6 bit “pretty” at times but ok

Nagy: 6 showed some nice touches to break the lines

Paterson: 5 quiet

Dasilva: 6 okay

Diedhiou: 5 not involved enough but little service

Semenyo: 5 not quite at it today

Subs:

Wells: looked really sharp and up for it - goal too

Martin: 6 brought a target

Brunt: 5 okay in ball, poor w/o it

Massengo: -

Edwards: -

Petty to dispute scores on a day no one shone, but I will ?

Rowe dose not play like someone who is as experienced as he is. Never drives forward, takes the easy backless option that I criticised Vyner for, except Vyner looks better lately. I would say Vyner slightly best of the 3 CB's

Though Semenyo at least hunted the ball, still looks a little raw but commits players.

That Nagy performance makes me want Paterson to be given a rest and bring in Bakinson. I'd rotate Pato and COD for that role, but 2 CMF's with energy could really help.

Teamsheet Tuesday will be interesting, as it stands not expecting much in the way of points. Saw a bit of QPR Friday and thought they looked decent.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

57 minutes ago, Rudolf Hucker said:

 

Bentley: 8 

Vyner: 5

Moore: 4

Rowe: 5

Hunt: 4

O’Dowda: 5

Nagy: 6

Paterson: 5

Dasilva: 5

Diedhiou: 4

Semenyo: 5

Subs:

Wells: 6

Martin: 5

Brunt: 4

Massengo: 3 only on for a few minutes but so so slow

Edwards: 5

I never do ratings but these are probably what I would say. I was disappointed in Moore and Vyner today in particular. 

I felt we have got lucky in a couple of games lately, got points or point when we probably shouldn’t have. Hopefully today will be a kick up the backside that we aren’t there yet, but I also feel 3-1 flattered Reading a bit.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Moore would get a 1 from me. The countless errors and two footed lunge were bad enough but on more than one occasion (including the last goal) he decided to stop trying. The other time was when he danced with Joao on the edge of the box before eventually just standing there and giving up, letting him just come inside and get a free shot off. Really pathetic.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bentley 8

Hunt 6

Vyner 6

Moore 5

Rowe 6

Dasilva 5

Nagy 5

O’Dowda 6

Paterson 5

Diedhiou 5

Semenyo 6

Subs

Martin 6

Wells 7

Brunt 5

Other two no time for a mark, but Edwards did at least try & make something happen, whereas HNM was completely off the pace.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...