Jump to content

JakeOTIB

Members
  • Posts

    177
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by JakeOTIB

  1. 16 minutes ago, 1960maaan said:

    This is a snapshot of the incident . Is this the split second the ball hit hand or a fraction of a second after when the hand has moved after being hit ? I'd say she had a decent view.

    Clear view of the arm out . Now I'd say a natural position for trying to block, but that changes when it stops the cross as he has gained an advantage.

    Screenshot2024-04-15at09_48_10.png.7752c1c496734f46384945abd68fea10.png

    Cross on it's way and you can clearly see raised arm.

    Screenshot2024-04-15at09_47_05.png.99abf9feabff68b301b2c3b5e32f1020.png

    Still able to see his arm after the ball has hit it.

    Screenshot2024-04-15at09_47_37.png.23e27a7aa53cba5d941fbf5f5b27b862.png

    I can't download this to slow mo it , I'll try and find it somewhere I can but I'm not hopeful.

     

    If it wasn’t sure before, I definitely am now; 100% a penalty, he’s stopped the cross going into the box with his raised arm. As I said before, I was in E28 so had a perfect side on view and this only ratified my original opinion.

    Granted I’d be furious if we gave something like this away in the last minute but rules are rules, just don’t shoot the messenger 🤷‍♂️

    • Like 3
  2. 13 minutes ago, Calculus said:

    Rugby doesn't finish when the clock reaches 80 though - the ball has to go out of play and that can take quite a while. 

    I’d have that in football too.

  3. 34 minutes ago, slartibartfast said:

    What was interesting was the fans in the South Stand immediately called for a penalty and it wasn't just a hopeful shout, either, it was a demand .

    As per my OP, I called for it because it looked stonewall to me.

    • Robin 1
  4. Re. extra time, does anybody else think the whole issue around added time could be solved by scrapping it completely and just stop the clock when the ball isn’t in play, when there’s an injury, substitution, goal etc. just like rugby? That way there can’t be any complaints and the game just finishes when it reaches 90 minutes.

  5. 2 minutes ago, Silvio Dante said:

    It’s really not.

    To give a parallel, let’s say you were a big fan of Star Wars and loved the original films. They were entertaining, fun and guaranteed you a good time.

    Now, The Phantom Menace comes out and George Lucas (in this case akin to Brian Tinnion) promises you a front foot film full of entertainment. 
     

    You then watch it and it’s an interminable bore about trade routes, with the comedy relief in Jar Jar Binks being painfully unfunny.

    Nobody would blame you for walking out of that cinema. Nobody.

    Well as a Star Wars fan, I do agree with the Jar Jar sentiment 😂 

    However I will say a good 2 minutes at the end of a football match can save it whilst a good 2 minutes at the end of a film won’t save it. At the end of the day people can do whatever, I just don’t agree with it.

    • Thanks 1
  6. I must be in the minority, but I genuinely thought that was a stonewall penalty…

    I was sat in Dolman E28 so it happened pretty much right infront of me and from that angle, it just looked blatant. Any one else agree with me or I’m I chatting a load of rubbish? Happy to be proved wrong.

    • Like 3
    • Thanks 1
×
×
  • Create New...