Jump to content
IGNORED

Ratings - Reading (a) 1-0 win


Davefevs

Recommended Posts

Bentley - 7 - clean sheet, good save early on (was it deflected), safe hands late on.

Hunt - 6 - solid, much better, covered alongside Williams.

Dasilva - 8 - great challenge from a cross in first half, and wizardry on the ball in second.  Returning to full sharpness, and looks for Paterson inside by getting his head up

Williams - 7 - assured after first minute slip.  Good positioning for goal line clearance

Baker - 8 - classy defensive display, close to a 9, but for some poor passing.  It stifles Dasilva at times.

Brownhill - 7 - much better, worked hard, and started to drive us on

Smith - 8 - so much to like in a good all round display.  Never doubt his sniffing out of danger, but some really intelligent passes too.  Returning to form at a key point.

Eliasson - 7 - quiet tonight, yet created all our chances.  Bit lightweight first half, but involved much more second half.  Class pass for the goal.

Paterson - 8 - key tonight to getting others to pass it / keep it.  Had quiet spells, but gave his all, and a super first time finish.

Weimann - 6 - actually looked like he might form a partnership with Fam playing narrow on left wing.  Unselfish 26/30 passes too.

Diedhiou - 7 - in line with recent performances.  Controlled aggression.  Good touch time Eliasson for goal.

O’Dowda - no Mark, but exactly what we wanted from a sub

Moore - no mark, in fact didn’t even get on the bbc live text!!! (Since been corrected)

4231 / 4141, however you want to look at it.  Played it for 90 minutes.  Didn’t even swap Eliasson and Weimann over.  Happy?  Yes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Davefevs said:

Bentley - 7 - clean sheet, good save early on (was it deflected), safe hands late on.

Hunt - 6 - solid, much better, covered alongside Williams.

Dasilva - 8 - great challenge from a cross in first half, and wizardry on the ball in second.  Returning to full sharpness, and looks for Paterson inside by getting his head up

Williams - 7 - assured after first minute slip.  Good positioning for goal line clearance

Baker - 8 - classy defensive display, close to a 9, but for some poor passing.  It stifles Dasilva at times.

Brownhill - 7 - much better, worked hard, and started to drive us on

Smith - 8 - so much to like in a good all round display.  Never doubt his sniffing out of danger, but some really intelligent passes too.  Returning to form at a key point.

Eliasson - 7 - quiet tonight, yet created all our chances.  Bit lightweight first half, but involved much more second half.  Class pass for the goal.

Paterson - 8 - key tonight to getting others to pass it / keep it.  Had quiet spells, but gave his all, and a super first time finish.

Weimann - 6 - actually looked like he might form a partnership with Fam playing narrow on left wing.  Unselfish 26/30 passes too.

Diedhiou - 7 - in line with recent performances.  Controlled aggression.  Good touch time Eliasson for goal.

O’Dowda - no Mark, but exactly what we wanted from a sub

Moore - no mark, in fact didn’t even get on the bbc live text!!! (Since been corrected)

4231 / 4141, however you want to look at it.  Played it for 90 minutes.  Didn’t even swap Eliasson and Weimann over.  Happy?  Yes.


I’d probably broadly agree. I know you don’t do half’s but I’d say (not that the latters played badly) that Smith and Baker deserved a slightly higher mark than Dasilva and Paterson but that’s nitpicking.

The Swift shot on Bentley first half wasn’t deflected but swerved wickedly. Better save than the highlights give it credit for.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, Davefevs said:

 

Baker - 8 - classy defensive display, close to a 9, but for some poor passing.  It stifles Dasilva at times.

 

4231 / 4141, however you want to look at it.  Played it for 90 minutes.  Didn’t even swap Eliasson and Weimann over.  Happy?  Yes.

Baker - not a great fan tbh purely because of his propensity to insist on going off the field when he gets a knock, can't be trusted. I may be doing him an injustice as he may have a long term injury we are unaware of, but it is very irritating. Imagine Baker without that weak point and imagine that he could pass the ball - he would't be with us if that were the case but what a player he would be. Very very good tonight fair play.

The point about starting with a defined formation/line up or whatever you want to call it, and not tinkering with it is a very good one. Every player looked as if they knew what their job was, it was a lot more cohesive than of late. Hopefully LJ will stay with it..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 hours ago, Silvio Dante said:

The Swift shot on Bentley first half wasn’t deflected but swerved wickedly. Better save than the highlights give it credit for.

Yes, big swerve and did well to save it, on TV it would have looked like poor goalkeeping if it went in.

Disappointed with Hunt, other than a couple of passes, very poor distribution and often appeared to be out of position and not picking players up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, East End Old Boy said:

Yes, big swerve and did well to save it, on TV it would have looked like poor goalkeeping if it went in.

Disappointed with Hunt, other than a couple of passes, very poor distribution and often appeared to be out of position and not picking players up.

There appears to be a very noticeable tactic that Hunt is being asked to play a lot closer to Williams to support him...Mrs ing he leaves more space out wide for the opposition left sided player.

It meant we conceded a lot of ball to Obita to swing in crosses.

However he only delivered 4/14 crosses that hit a Reading teammate.

If you take corners out of the equation (2/3), only 2 of his 11 crosses found their man....one of which was what led to the melee.  But ultimately, we dealt with his crosses really well.

C861BFFB-BDFD-44B3-B047-95931DBD7D2A.thumb.jpeg.49152fe7483e23c75dd0598bc90cc207.jpeg

Compare to our own Niclas Eliasson....4/7 of which 1/1 were corners.  So 3/6 found a teammate.

2D1D1F7C-3B94-4574-8625-9AE6CDAC4DE8.thumb.jpeg.cd14d2905462ab822810d36ea32db58c.jpeg

Finally of those 3 (out of 6) successful open play crosses, all of Nic’s were chance assists (light blue line).  Only 1 of Obita’s was.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

20 hours ago, Davefevs said:

Bentley - 7 - clean sheet, good save early on (was it deflected), safe hands late on.

Hunt - 6 - solid, much better, covered alongside Williams.

Dasilva - 8 - great challenge from a cross in first half, and wizardry on the ball in second.  Returning to full sharpness, and looks for Paterson inside by getting his head up

Williams - 7 - assured after first minute slip.  Good positioning for goal line clearance

Baker - 8 - classy defensive display, close to a 9, but for some poor passing.  It stifles Dasilva at times.

Brownhill - 7 - much better, worked hard, and started to drive us on

Smith - 8 - so much to like in a good all round display.  Never doubt his sniffing out of danger, but some really intelligent passes too.  Returning to form at a key point.

Eliasson - 7 - quiet tonight, yet created all our chances.  Bit lightweight first half, but involved much more second half.  Class pass for the goal.

Paterson - 8 - key tonight to getting others to pass it / keep it.  Had quiet spells, but gave his all, and a super first time finish.

Weimann - 6 - actually looked like he might form a partnership with Fam playing narrow on left wing.  Unselfish 26/30 passes too.

Diedhiou - 7 - in line with recent performances.  Controlled aggression.  Good touch time Eliasson for goal.

O’Dowda - no Mark, but exactly what we wanted from a sub

Moore - no mark, in fact didn’t even get on the bbc live text!!! (Since been corrected)

4231 / 4141, however you want to look at it.  Played it for 90 minutes.  Didn’t even swap Eliasson and Weimann over.  Happy?  Yes.

Good stuff Dave - Dasilva is looking like a class signing now .... another in our long line of superb left backs that goes all the way back to the 70s ... ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...