ciderwithtommy

He looks the real deal to me. Pace, movement, aggression, instinctive goals. Every game I’ve seen him in the first team he has either scored, or come close. But most importantly, he seems eager and able to learn quickly, reminds me a little if Joe Bryan in that respect, however he is doing at a higher level, earlier in his career. Could he be the semenyo  replacement - and go beyond him? 

This is where the King signing has to be looked at, can we really use him when needed and expect much from him? Feels like he is a good last resort option, but it looks like he could well be called in for long parts of this season. Given Williams and James injury record, and Kings for that matter, CM looks so light. 

Completely hypothetical- and of course open to debate, but this current team/squad, I would want Cotts in charge out of the the list given. Excellent at giving players a platform to play to their strengths, and creates and us v them attitude. After that, maybe GJ but think he struggled with more established pros, and Pearson. The rest, not so much. Honourable mention to Coppell of course 

I don’t think we will sell him this summer, I think our model has changed slightly. Under previous CEO Semenyo would be all but gone already, with all parties involved gaining a nice bit of dough and limelight along the way. In fact I would imagine we would’ve been actively talking to agents. Of course, under the old model a replacement would’ve been bought, who again would’ve suited all parties from a financial perspective. 
 

New regime won’t turn down a crazy offer - which I think only a few prem clubs would do, but will try and get him to Jan 23 minimum before we cash in. Fairly confident he will be here first game of season, really hope I am right!

Losing semenyo to Bournemouth would be such a sickener. To me the exemplify so much of what is wrong in modern football, breached FFP, invested poorly in first season down, and then pretty much bought promotion, all on crowds of 12k. Sign of the times I guess, but it is a tough one to stomach. 

Re Duff, his mentor is…. Cotts - small world…

Yep Baker will have insurance, which pays out based on expected earnings after the point at which his injury forced him to retire. Based on what he has earnt to date in his career, it’s likely a big sum. No sugar coating how gutting it is for him tho, feel for him, what a huge blow if it is true. 

Such a talent, at times for us I think he was underrated in terms of how good he was, and the level he played at, for a good 12-18 months. Shared a few drinks with him in Pam Pams over the years, really funny guy - but couldn’t help but think his social life held him back from being elite. 

4 minutes ago, AppyDAZE said:

Still can't for the life of me understand why Han-Noah doesn't just drag him back. That was more of a mistake than the mistake.

Gutted for the result, but still on the up with the performances.

This is so true, hamer etc from their team take the booking and stop the attack. But that’s a learning curve for our players, they seem to be learning at the moment - next season hopefully we see the learning come to fruition 

10 minutes ago, sh1t_ref_again said:

You said, 

Pring in the same situation takes the man and the ball and leaves yiadom in a heap, 

Cod seen a cross field ball played that he spinted out to try and make an interception, but the Reading player got to 1st. Had he kept going and left the player in a heap as you suggest, would have been penalised by any ref let alone the idiot last night.

As I am not jumping on the let's crusify Cod for anything we can bandwagon, so I seen it as a good effort to try and nick the cross field ball to start a break, but got beaten to the ball.

Man and ball equals a red card? Don’t agree with you there at all. Not condoning a two footer etc but  you have to be aggressive.

also, neither of them touch the ball, it’s embarrassing. The point is so obvious, he’s shot. It’s not that I don’t have sympathy for him, he is struggling, but I’ve watched too much of it, I’m done with excuses, time to move on.

Just now, sh1t_ref_again said:

Yeah great and gets sent off by a ref giving a foul for the slightest of touches all night 

Defending a player pulling out of a tackle because the ref was poor? So do you think odowda thought “ooh hold on dont commit to this cos the ref is fussy?”. I’m not condoning reckless, but football is a contact sport and that ball was there to be won, he simply has to do more. And it’s not isolated to just that incident, or even this game. 

Odowda - never has been, never will be a winner. Just hasn’t got that mentality. You are 2-0 up against a terrible team, and when you come on you put in that performance. That was the play of a guy who wanted to hide, get out of there unscathed, survive. Not take it to them, stamp his authority and make it 3/4 nil. Simply put he plays like a loser (sporting wise) and we have to weed that out down here ASAP. 
 

when he pulls out of the cross field pass, that sums him up at city. Pring in the same situation takes the man and the ball and leaves yiadom in a heap, and allows semenyo and Weimann to counter. benarous from what I’ve seen is game, and would be in there fighting. The youngsters are showing how yellow he is, no more appearances unless it’s injury enforced for me. Had his chances and simply not taken them. 
 

Re Ayling, I believe he was in more trouble for the Cheltenham antics within his own personal bubble as he was here at the club. A move away from the social group he had was also a part of the reason, along with LJ never really fancying him.

For me the Ashton era will be defined by how keen we were to “trade”. You have to sell to the prem is a phrase I’ve heard a few times, and I believe there is an element of truth to it. However do we truly believe other teams in our league haven’t had prem interest in their players but held onto them?  If we had only been better in recruiting the need to sell so heavily wouldn’t have been there. Selling a Webster like deal should’ve put us in a position where all other talent was ring fenced for at Least a year, but no we bought terribly and then had to sell more assets. 
 

it’s like you own a house, it’s a nice house, you are happy living in it. If you want to keep Living there, and can afford to do so, happy days. But Ashton was the estate agent who puts your house on right move and courts offers, you then think “might be a good idea to sell”. But the whole process is kinda unnecessary, and it leaves you needing a new house in the same area. 
 

the question I have always had, why did MA want to trade so much? Only 2 things I can think, 1 it raised his own profile, and 2 he benefitted from player sales in one way or other…

On 29/11/2021 at 22:56, Lrrr said:

I was told Ipswich saw someone who had all the physical attributes to be a top player who they could teach the game and skills to and help them develop to the required standard 

Heard exactly the same from his teammates in non league. Not stand out technically in any way, but clearly had the athletic capabilities to compete in the pro game. Add that to the fact the kid was, and apparently still is, truly dedicated to the nutrition/science he has just continued to develop. I can accept missing these types of player as he is a huge outlier, but would prefer if we didn’t miss them 

There was a passage in the second half where Stoke were on top, and Goodman said “this is much better” - then 6 seconds of silence before he says “for Stoke”. 100% odds on a producer was in his ear haha.

That said, I don’t care - if anything I always have enjoyed supporting us v “the elite”. We are to a degree an unknown club to lots of pundits, we aren’t in a football hotspot like the NW or Midlands. They are, in the most part, as thick as whale omelettes. Long may it continue, a promotion (at some point in the future) would taste even sweeter.

Might be mentioned elsewhere but is Tanner injured?

Benarous showing exactly what we have missed for 18months. Ability to keep the ball in tight spaces, and a desire to be a winner at all costs. Unreal it’s taken a 18 y/o to show our older lads how’s its done, but there you go! 

3 minutes ago, The Dolman Pragmatist said:

1 minute ago, Davefevs said:

I had no reason to doubt that the person who told me “Nige gone” was right (his source from within the club too)…but it proved to be wrong.

It kept OTIB busy over a dull international break though.

I think he may well have been gone, but then things can change very quickly in employment law 

I know there have been rumours online which I won’t put here as I don’t wanna get banned, but heard today from multiple sources that those rumours are bang on the money. It seems off the pitch we are as much if not more of a mess than on it. 

I listened to it, and in fairness twentypence said that the club had set this up - so credit to RG for doing so. GT was pretty direct so no surprise it wasn’t the perfect interview, we can all see how bad it is on the pitch so even the best public speaker would struggle. 
 

my opinion - health is the most important thing, so fully behind Nige taking time and wish him a speedy, full recovery.  There is very little that the club can say, from an HR perspective, even if he was set to leave. But it wouldn’t surprise me to hear news of him leaving in the next 7 days. There is more to life. 

RG should be talking to Nige once he is well enough, and ask if he wants to be here. This job is too tough for anyone with doubts about the role (whatever the doubts are). If he is keen, back him properly and accept that even sir Alex would struggle with this squad. If he wants out, let him go and appoint a young team with a clear identity, but knowing that likely means league one next season.

we are reaping what Ashton sowed in his final 18 months whilst he was likely flirting with Ipswich, and no doubt others. 
 

either way, the demand RG has to make is that we see a style of play and identity in the next 10 games, what we are seeing right now is not acceptable. 

His highlight reel would be epic tonight. Not having the “good with his feet” shout tonight, he gave away good possession on multiple occasions. I don’t blame him hugely tho, expecting a guy at his age to lead the line week in week out at this level is a joke.
 

We need 2 strikers minimum - else it’s a long old season. Week after week we see the opposition strikers turn water in to wine, ours do the opposite. How far we have fallen is sad.

Yes

No width at all, nothing up front. We are so easy to play against its untrue. Not one player in the whole squad who can beat a man on the outside, truly appalling squad balance that makes us easy pray for any team with half a plan. 6 players short minimum, take 20th place but then what?