Might be age, or rose tinted glasses, but the most spectacular bit of skill I can recall was performed by Marco Van Gavin.
89-90 season I think we were playing Huddersfield at the gate late in the season. He turned 3 defenders in the box with a feint and a dummy stepover and turn, which gave him enough room to get a shot away. He didn't score, but the ball fell to Nicky Morgan who did. Think we drew 1-1. We needed the point as God had done his hammy against Crewe and we were struggling to get over the line.