Jump to content

Better Red

Members
  • Posts

    819
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Better Red

  1. 19 minutes ago, Tim Monaghan said:

    Agreed, Ipswich are a lot quicker than us moving the ball forward. But I believe that KM is as suited to a slower build up to, he just needs the service. 

    image.png.a352841393cdd5181b9879b9fff07a32.png

     

    Pring and Vyner are better.

    Max Bird will also likely start.

    • Like 1
  2. 33 minutes ago, RobImps said:

    True.

    But, the arguement against your point is we haven't had any success or entertainment value playing a possession based game under Manning..

    I don't believe we have the players to do that.

     

    When a team sits back is generally when the stadium falls asleep and social media erupts ... Because it's boring to watch and the result will be poor.

     

    Can Manning sign players so we can play both styles and have an answer for all circumstances? Time will tell

     

     

    Twine, Sykes and the new winger will give us better options to break down teams who sit deeper.
     

    QPR is a good test for the team and Manning after 2 good wins. 

    Can they have 60% possession and still win? 

    • Like 1
  3. Vyner is probably the most important player to keep fit in the squad.

    No real replacement for him. Only Pring could do a similar job with ‘pace’

    Dickie needs pace along side him. Needs Vyners  as cover when he moves into midfield with the ball.

    They make a very combination.

    Vyner most unsung player in the team maybe with Tanner both are having really good seasons. 

    • Like 2
  4. We have a squad with competition better than ever.

    When Sykes and Twine back it will be a tough call to get a best 11.

    Only goal keeper and Centre Half do we now lack competition. 


    Need to keep Vyner and Max fit. Most other positions we have good options.

    We just need a little more quality in the summer and we will be close to the top 6.

     

  5. 1 hour ago, And Its Smith said:

    Manning getting a fair bit of criticism for this yesterday and it’s completely fair to say that the two halves from us looked completely different to each other.  Changing shape when 2-0 up at half time isn’t something you see very often.  But I think, whether one agrees with a decision or not, it is always worth considering why it was made.  Comments of ‘baffling decision’ suggest a lack of thought as to why the decision might have been taken.  You can disagree with a decision but still understand the thought process behind it.  Something that doesn’t happen too often on OTIB, or most football forums I would guess.  
     

    When you consider the following it looks much more of an understandable decision:

    1.  5 at the back has conceded just 2 goals in 400 minutes of football against Premier League opposition 

    2. The second half against Preston would be fresh in his mind

    3. No league win since Boxing Day

    4. A bit of a trend (although diminishing) of conceding early second half goals

     

    Maybe there are other reasons as well but if you put yourself in Manning’s shoes, I think it is more understandable than it appeared at 4pm yesterday.  I think he was vindicated as well.  Max had a few saves to make but we weren’t massively tested.  Their goal was lucky as well which probably put a further negative spin on the win for some.  

    Objective get three points away from home at Middlesbrough.

    Rest a few players where possible as another 2 games this week

    Dont give away a 2 goal lead.

    Tick

    Tick

    Tick

     

    • Like 3
    • Thanks 1
    • Robin 1
  6. 1 minute ago, Leabrook said:

    So I wasn’t making it up then?  Also wrong on Vyner and Conway.  
     

    I will accept your apology!  

    I can’t see Conway or Vyner mentioned in the above 

    Vyner was already a first team player - so why refer to him

    Conway in Aug 21 I don’t he played until a few times that season

    I did you the list what more can I do.

    Also forgot Pearson - Tick

    Like I said wisdom

    Well a apart from Scott & Max I will give you that but glad they proved me wrong (Scott very wrong)

    They are just opinions some will be right and some will be wrong.

    I just get more right than wrong.

    Not because I am a genius. Simply I saw what I see. 

    I have seen enough football to warrant having opinion.

    Others will have diff ones - that’s cool. We can all see the same game/players differently.

    If we don’t post an opinion then we would not have this forum. 
     

    Get some right, get some wrong and that is the beauty of football and all that comes with it.

     

     

  7. 1 minute ago, Leabrook said:

    There’s the bit on Scott. Can show you the rest if you like.  
     

    Over 50 years old and goes a forum to wind people up and accuse people of lying when pulled up on it 

    IMG_0369.png

    Like I said wisdom…

    Not a million miles off.

    Seymeno -  Half Tick

    Edwards - Tick

    Bakinson  - Tick

    Bell - Tick

    Scott - won’t score goals - Tick 

    Scott - needed loan - very wrong 

    Max - Wrong 

     

  8. 40 minutes ago, Mr Popodopolous said:

    How about change back to a 4-3-3 or similar for one.

    I don't think this current shape will especially work for us. Maybe it will when all are fit time will tell but when Bell who is not a left sided player is at RWB, when Tanner is kinda shoehorned in at CB..then there is the risk Sykes return and the impact will be negated by putting him at Wingback.

    Agree - Sykes needs to play wide right in a front three.

    Best attacking player we have and pre injury arguably the best player we had.

    Some tough decisions for Manning Tanner vs McCorie 

    Midfield 2 to play with Twine.

    who plays wide on the left.

    What Manning does have is lots of options and competition.

    Maybe not enough quality but that is what I hope we fix in the summer.

    I don’t think we are miles away.

    The one that made me think last night was Dickie.


    Up to this point he was for me a no brainier but last night showed up the gap we need to get closer to if not close for our next step.

  9. 1 hour ago, Leabrook said:

    The same wisdom that said Vyner not good enough. The same wisdom that said Alex Scott needed a two year loan to league one and wouldn’t play in the premier league. The same wisdom that said Max would never make the first team.  The same wisdom that said Conway should go out on loan before he then went on to score a ton of goals

     

    Your track record is so bad.  

    Your making it up now….

    Wisdom and also humility 

    Agree re Max - I said yesterday he is proving me wrong in the last few months 

  10. Just now, Leabrook said:

    The same wisdom that used to slag off semenyo 

    ‘Slag Off’ - read the post

    Said not a Striker he wont score goals.

    I said he will never get to 10 in a season.

    Check out he’s record and tell me I am wrong.

    Call it Wisdom….

    • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...