I personally think a 4-4-1-1 suits us best, with Semenyo and O'Dowda playing out wide, Weimann in behind Martin. It's an easy shape for the players to know their roles and it can be flexible.
You might say Semenyo isn't a wide player but he's shown he can support a right back. He would also be able to frequesntly swap with Weimann which gives defenders a difficult challenge.
Scott would then he back up for Weimann and Semenyo and I'd use him in every game.
I still think we'd have to suffer some lapses of football common sense, but that's always going to be the case this season with the profile of our squad.
Importantly, I think this gives us threat in several areas, and more pace and trickery.