Nogbad the Bad Posted May 23, 2009 Report Share Posted May 23, 2009 Elliott - top class. Superb signing. Izzy - solid defender. Not good, not bad, not a gamble. Ordinary. McIndoe - not bad for this level. Very good signing. Sproule - not bad for this level. No. Sproule is far from Championship quality and surely should be replaced. Poor signing. Maynard - Alot of potential. Good signing so far and even more so in the long run. Williams - Could be good given opportunity. Injury prone, time will tell if Williams is value for money and a good signing or not. Trundle - Not that bad, big shame he didn't get chance this season after doing so well in playoffs. Good signing, well, I enjoyed watching him anyway. Henderson - Looks quality. Probably will be, but only a good signing if he goes on to be City No. 1. Akinde - loads of potential. Yes, but can only be classified as a good signing if he makes the grade at the Gate. Carle - £500k profit. Did nothing much for City, so can't be called a good signing, profit or not. Dele - very solid. Good old Dele, good signing. Styvar - Jury's out. It is, but only because of latterly disclosed illness. Looks for all the world like a poor signing. We shall see. Stern John. About as bad a signing as they come. Basso, Fontaine, McAllister, Johnson and Wilson all good signings. On the whole GJ gets it right far more often than not. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.