Ayling yes. Pack no way, been caught in possession too often and looks slow off the mark.
This was after 36 mins, when Pack had been caught in posession ONCE! Not too often, ONCE.
Freeman not impressed with Pack's pass there
Pack has been incredibly frustrating 1st half. Poor decision making and his passing has been way off.
Overhit 1 cross-field pass up to this point, and played 2 through balls out of play, in attempting to force forward play. By this stage Korey had given the ball away numerous time too, but no comment on him.
Look closer to home Pack not good enough for league one let alone championship
Written off already.
I'm sorry but Pack is well out of his depth here.
Written off already
Was thinking the same
Written off already
Pack booked
Deary me
What a great reaction to someone getting booked. It'll happen to all of our players this season, hope they all get a "deary me". Pack was booked for 'taking one for the team', bringing down a man who was going to run through. Good booking in my opinion.
It's gonna be a long old season for Pack
Written off already
Marlon pack,just letting his man run.shocking
This was the comment on the 2nd goal. Where Pack tracked back with the man from the edge of the Sheff box, all the way to half way inside our own half. Initially the break was 3 on 3, but Pack correctly didn't dive in, and held the man from running all the way through on goal. The fact the cross wasn't stopped, and then Fielding went awol is not the fault of the midfielder who tracked 50+ yards and jockeyed his man well.
As you said SuperBob, you're judging him on previous, which is fine. I think a lot of people would say he looked more than just "ok" in L1, so I do think your mind is already made up.
Only one game but Pack has looked particularly off the pace to me today out of everyone but no one is pulling up trees by any stretch.
Exactly. One game, where you admit that no one looked good, yet Pack is the one singled out.
Packs lack of pace nearly leads to a third...
You mean the one when Korey lost it on the half way line, Pack chased the man back, Flint came flying out and overshot his challenge, leaving Pack the only man left, who was beaten for pace by a lad from Portugal who's arrived in this league with one main attribute - pace. I think Joao would've beaten anyone to that ball bar Burns.
I think we will struggle with Pack in midfield this season.
Written off already
Pack looked niggly and got caught in possession too many times, he also misplaced too many passes but he was probably my only major criticism.
Got caught in possession 3 times I think. Less than Korey, Fredericks, Freeman, Wilbs. Mis-placed a couple of passes in the 1st half, but much better radar in the 2nd. Smith, Williams, Bryan to name a few mis-placed just as many if not more passes, yet he was your only major criticism?
A lot to think about, though what happened to our midfield? Number of times we had possession in defence but had no options.
The midfield saw plenty of ball (how else could they have so say mis-placed sooo many passes.
The fact the CB's chose to hit diagonals too often was not the fault of the midfield, it's a tactic we adopted plenty last season.
Anyone else with me in thinking the transfer priorities should be a box to box midfielder (replacing Pack). As for the midfielder I'm not sure if Pack is championship quality, think we need someone to go forward more.
Written off already. This guy wants his shiedling midfielder to go forward more!
I think we need more of a defensive midfielder to replace Pack to be honest.
Written off already.
Midfield was always going to be a problem, even in some game last season, our midfield didn't dominate or control
Written off already, and clearly a shot at Pack, not Korey - cuz no one critiscises Korey, even when he's had a stinker today!
Pack is my main worry for this season. His performance against Swindon last season should have rang all the alarm bells. Against anyone with pace he is toast. His solution is dodgy freekicks on the edge of our box. We desperately need a good, pacy central midfielder.
Written off already. How many free kicks on the edge of the box were given away today? I remember Freeman giving one.
Pack imho was the weak link last season and he's had a stinker today. Its early days yet and he did finish the season on a high, improving greatly, I'm not fighting him off yet bit on todays performance he looked way out of his depth
Everyone had a stinker today. All bar Flint looked out of their depth today.
I like Pack but he does make a lot of bad choices in dangerous areas, his radar was a bit off today and gave it away too much.
As said before, gave it away 3 or 4 times in the first half, but was much more accurate 2nd half. Others gave the ball away many more times, but aren't receiving critique.
End of the day pack was awful which left smith so exposed,if pack can't pass 10 yards without giving it away then we are in trouble
Gave it away about 4 times. 2 cross-field diagonals, and a couple of attempted incisive passes. Don't think it was a case of not being able to pass it 10 yards. Korey's passing was worse than Pack's today, but no antagonism levelled his way?
I appreciate SuperBob that a couple of posters have given their rationale and are perfectly entitled to their opinion, but I don't think I'm being naive at all mate. Read the 20 or so quoted posts above and tell me that some people aren't going over the top a bit, based on 1 performance where he was nowhere near our worst player.
Thanks for the opinion you perfectly entitled to. But do you seriously think Korey played crap because Pack played crap? Korey was poor in his own right, as were many others.
Again, read the previous posts and tell me there isn't an element of boo boy mentality in them.
What's tiresome is the entirely predictable backlash that Pack receives from some fans whenever he plays. Many are still judging him on half a dozen games at the start of Sod's reign. Pack has more than proven himself over last season, just like Flint, Williams & Fielding, who also had pretty slow starts under Sod, but they've all been forgiven it seems. Mr Pack just can't shake it off with some fans, despite being one of our most consistent performers in the last 20-25 games last season.
Samo. I'm not calling everyone a boo boy, but just look at how many people have written him off after 1 game, a game in which he was nowhere near our worst player, and in which none of our team covered themselves in glory.
I use the term boo boy quite deliberately, because believe me, I can see it only being a matter of time (and a few defeats), before fans at the ground will start getting vocal. Some of that will have stemmed from the untruths spoken on here about his performances. Once it starts, it won't stop, and will spiral into jeers at the ground.
I think today was a poor day all round for all of our players. Fielding, Williams, Fredericks, Ayling, Smith, Freeman, Wilbraham & Kodjia could ALL have fair criticism levelled at them today after their performances, yet the only player getting singled out is Pack. That's why I use the term boo boy, because there are a number of posters who are singling Pack out for special treatment, and that's not right.
I'm not saying Pack is the answer, and I would happily upgrade him and a few others in the team for much better players, but the way some people are writing, is that he's the worst player in the squad by a mile, and he's far from it.