Jump to content

Eco

Members
  • Posts

    3113
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Eco

  1. Just my opinion, but however bad this tour has been it doesn't out do all the good Flower has done for the England team. Give him the summer to see if he can get England back to winning ways.

    I've said for a while but some of the squad has to go and start a rebuilding process, KP to go, Carberry to go, Prior too and maybe Bell although i'm not sure there.

     

    Bring in the likes of James Taylor, I'd give Gary Ballance another chance, give Root a number and stick to it! If he opens new middle order guy (maybe Taylor) if he's 5/6 then either Compton for a year or 2 (like before Carberry needs to go, Compton was more impressive in his spell as opener imo, he was playing for a place in the side and throwing the bat as an opener) before someone like Sam Robson, or go for a Varun Chopra/Alex Hales, records not as impressive but hope they can make the step up.

    Bit harsh on Carb's he was by no means our worst batter & deserves a chance against SL & India, not a lot older than Compo.

     

    I think Bell has to stay and agree about Prior and KP. Will be interesting to see if Trott's illness is reserved for away trips only or is similar to Tresco's, if he recovers then will hold down no.3 spot with Bell 4 Root 5 Buttler 6 Stokes 7 Broad 8 Finn 9 Anderson 10 & Monty 11

  2. He could drop Wes.... that's what SOD would do, and wouldn't think twice about it either.

    The Least agro decision is drop Wes and keep Taylor on the bench ..... job done.... of course i hope that doesn't happen

     another interesting decision needs to be made re the fact that Fontaine is in the 18 man squad now, again would you drop Carey ?

    if you try and name an 18 man squad for Saturday, then you will see what i mean about some tough decisions over the next few weeks.

    two will miss out plus Brundle

    Will it be Wes and Louis ? i really hope not

    To be fair to SOD he did play Wes quite a bit last season, just saying...

  3. Crazy decision to play two ashes tours so close together, R5 was reporting last night that England have played more tests recently than any other nation. Still poor to fold that easily, but ashes series 3 months apart!!

    And we're playing them again in 2015, bit  of an overkill ?

  4. Fair enough if that is what you believe, but he is out with the England Performance Squad in Aus atm and has scored a couple of 100's in games.

    Never really liked it going back to Allan Lamb/Chris & Robin Smith days, makes a mockery of playing for your country. Imo of course

  5. Anderson will still play when in England as no one swings a ball like him in England, when touring it may be a different story.

     

    Agree KP gone, Panesar won't stay nor will Prior I don't think. Bresnan won't stay in.

     

    I'd like to see something like: Cook, Root, Taylor, Bell, Ballance, Stokes, Bairstow/Buttler/Kieswetter, Broad, Borthwick, Anderson, Finn.

     

    Also one awful series, I don't think Flower should be kicked. Lets see if it acts as a reality check and how they do next summer. Flower has done an incredible amount for the England side.

    I really don't think Joe Root is an opener, trouble is Carbs & Compo haven't really impressed and are both getting on a bit, is there anyone else on the circuit ?

×
×
  • Create New...