Jump to content

Henry

Members
  • Posts

    3765
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Henry

  1. 10 hours ago, Davefevs said:

    I know what you’re saying, but I disagree with the words.  Who is the best at helping us get points, would be my words.

    I’d go with that, but that starts with keeping clean sheets or conceding less.

    To use a crude example, all things being equal,  if we win 4-3 with Max but lose 0-1 with Dan….then you pick Max every game don’t you?

    Not really. It depends what part the keeper has played in those goals. If Max has thrown 3 into his net (or he scores a hat trick!) then it has an effect. I’d lean towards Bentley as it’s more like a keeper has had an direct impact of the team conceding 3 than the team scoring 4.

    But obviously it isn’t as simple as that.  I do think @Fordy62is right in that I think Antoine’s return is more responsible for our better forward play, with a small part down to Max’s distribution.

    The question becomes, if Dan gets picked, does it stifle Antoine / our attacking?

    I don’t know.

    What I would say is that if Dan could get back to a comparable level with his feet as Max (because his kicking has fallen off a Cliff) then I’d pick Bents every time.

    A keeper in todays game is not just about what he does with shots and crosses, it’s important, don’t get me wrong.  But they touch the ball more with their feet than their hands.

    It would be good to see Dan back, with a kicking game much improved.

    I think Bentley needs to come back, I’m confident that Bentley would have stop some of these goals that Max has conceded. Watching the Cardiff highlights a couple days later you realise we conceded two terrible goals that could have cost us.

  2. I thought he looked a bit stronger than when he played last season. There were a few times he followed his man to the half way line to get a foot in.

    Ive certainly seen worse defensive performances from experienced defenders,

    • Like 2
  3. 35 minutes ago, billywedlock said:

    Pearson said on RB that he thought Bentley has not been at his best and that Max was looking good. The only rules he is referring too is that when you get your chance you have to take it, and the player dropped has to work themselves back in. 

    I actually like Max and we should be pleased we have good options in goal. Both have slightly different skills . 

    I’m amazed so many people either have missed the point or are deliberately trying to paint Bentley in a bad light.

    People forget Bentley has been one of our best players for years.

    • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...